• Question: I previously asked a question surrounding consciousness and human perception. I had really insightful answers... but from those I found myself asking questions surrounding colours and sound. As a human we only have 3 colour receptors and we can only hear specific sound frequencies. In the future could we adapt this and change it using medical practises or have we really reached our biological limits as a human species? Thank you :)

    Asked by anon-284017 on 8 Mar 2021.
    • Photo: Alex Baxendale

      Alex Baxendale answered on 8 Mar 2021:


      Ahh I think I mentioned these! The biggest problem we have, is if we have a way to overcome the limits of our eyes and ears, our brains can’t cope with the information. The basic auditory and visual perception areas of our brains are mapped out 1:1 with the sense. So the Cochlea which responds to sounds in the ear is laid out from low to high frequencies, and just like that the primary auditory area that processes what sounds actually are are also mapped out from low to high frequencies. This leads us with a problem as we don’t have space to process higher or lower frequencies that we haven’t been born with. So unfortunately we can’t get eye or ear implants to process the frequencies because the brain itself is also limited (perhaps another scientist might know if it is possible for the brain to learn new frequencies and colours through neuroplasticity?).
      The only way I could see a future for us to perceive this information is maybe using technology for some kind of brain implant? But I have no idea if that would even be possible

    • Photo: David McGonigle

      David McGonigle answered on 8 Mar 2021:


      Hiya again, Anastacia! Wow…another exciting question! Alex has already got straight to the heart of your topic, and is absolutely spot on – say we had some way to plug a new microphone into the brain that was able to record the ultrasonic ‘chirps’ bats use when they are navigating (these are 2/3x higher that the highest frequencies we can hear). What bit of the brain would we ‘plug’ this extra information into? There’s no ‘room’ in our auditory cortex, which contains a ‘map’ of sound frequencies rather like a piano keyboard, laid out along a strip of brain. The analogy doesn’t end there: like a piano, there is no easy way to just bolt on new keys with new frequencies to expand that range. You’re stuck!

      But it *is* possible to change the wiring in your brain to accept inputs that are not perceived in nature by humans. Take our bat chirps: we could take the signal from our super-sensitive bat microphone, combine it with a bit of neurosurgical knowhow (again…not one to try at home!), and wire that input directly our auditory cortex. The problem is…again, as Alex says, there’s no room, so you’d need to lose something. It would be like taking your piano keys, cutting the connection between some keys and their ‘hammers’, and rewiring each one.
      So have we reached our biological limits? Well, yes and no. Surprisingly (I had totally forgotten this until I googled it), there *are* human tetrachromats: people with 4 colour receptors, instead of 3 that most of us get by with! It’s quite a decent percentage of the population, with roughly 12% of women having 4 colour receptors…but don\t get your hopes up. Most tetrachromats report that their condition doesn’t allow them to see any ‘new’ colours – what it does do is tend to give them an ability to perceive colours – and the differences between them – in richer detail. Bummer! But not all is lost – if we can’t tweak our current senses, maybe we can borrow a new one? Back to our bats: there is a growing amount of evidence that humans can use a limited form of echolocation to get around. While it really started in the blind – this video is a lovely introduction https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A8lztr1tu4o – the skill can be learned by sighted humans, as well. Have fun researching this a bit more!

    • Photo: Harry Piper

      Harry Piper answered on 11 Mar 2021:


      Ohh! This is a really interesting question and the other scientists have got great answers so I won’t add to what they’ve said in any way but talk about a fly (which I have done before, I’m not sure why I’m obsessed with this example) .
      When a fly is buzzing around the window and we open it wider o help it get out, it seems to really struggle – it can’t process the information in the same way we can (we can clearly se how it should move to leave) – this gives a really interesting idea as to what can’t we perceive – it has already been mentioned about colour and also sound frequencies, but maybe there are additional things we can’t see (cool alter dimensions that we are missing out on!). This comes to opinion on if these things (additional dimensions etc.) exist, whereas other colour and sound we know from science!

Comments