• Question: What are the chances there are aliens on Mars?

    Asked by Martha on 22 Nov 2021.
    • Photo: Andrew McDowall

      Andrew McDowall answered on 22 Nov 2021:


      It seems very unlikely we’ll discover any form of advanced life on Mars, but the prospects of something more basic are rather better.
      The suface environment on Mars is very harsh – cold, dry, oxidising and with a high radiation flux. The subsurface environment and the historical surface environment look to be rather better so it’s possible life might have evolved and retreated as the surface environment decayed. Certainly on Earth we find life in the most extraordinary environments, capable of tollerating and thriving in conditions that you would have expected to be instantly lethal, environments kind of similar to those on Mars, so it is possible, but on Earth there has been a long period of time for organisms to develop the complex mechanisms needed and then adapt them to the extreme environments. It’s a question as to whether the environment on Mars was benign enough, for long enough, for these mechanisms to evolve and adapt before the planet lost most of its atmosphere and became a radiation-blasted desert.
      At the moment I’m pessimistic regarding the prospect of finding any life of any sort on Mars (not accidentally carried recently from Earth) in the reasonable future. If there is any it’s likely to be buried deep and I’m not sure there was time before Mars froze. But our understanding of the Martian environment and history is advancing so rapidly (and also our understanding of the conditions life can endure on Earth) that anything we think we know is likely to be rewritten in weeks or months and the great thing about science is you get to change your mind.

    • Photo: Alexander De Bruin

      Alexander De Bruin answered on 23 Nov 2021:


      I came here to say what Andrew did, only less eloquently!

    • Photo: Alexander Munnoch

      Alexander Munnoch answered on 23 Nov 2021:


      I defer to Andrew’s answer on this one!

    • Photo: Natasha Marchant

      Natasha Marchant answered on 26 Nov 2021:


      Andrew has given a very thorough answer!
      I think if their were aliens of the sci-fi movie type, we would have discovered them on mars already or at least some evidence of them. As Andrew said, there is a better possibility of very basic life forms but again, nothing found so far! I think it’s more likely to find advanced life forms (or aliens if you prefer) in other solar systems very far away!

Comments